Episode 109
NT Tax Code Rejections & UK Pensions: Why Is Accessing Your Money So Difficult?
For British expats in America, accessing a UK pension can be far more complicated than it should be. HMRC is rejecting NT tax code applications, providers won’t deal with US residents, and some pensions offer little flexibility when it’s time to take your money.
In this From the Trenches episode of Expat Wealth, Richard Taylor and James Boyle revisit NT tax code rejections, sharing further experiences reported by clients and listeners. They also explore the frustrations of old UK pensions, from limited investment choices to “zombie” insurance companies and explain why they typically recommend international SIPPs for their US-based clients.
Whether retirement is approaching or still years away, they discuss why currency control, investment options and access matter, and the potential cost of leaving your pension untouched until you need it.
—
Expat Wealth is supported by Plan First Wealth. Plan First Wealth is a Registered Investment Advisor serving fellow expatriates and immigrants living across the US on matters such as retirement planning, investment management, tax planning and non-US asset management.
—
Expat Wealth is affiliated with Plan First Wealth LLC, an SEC registered investment advisor. The views and opinions expressed in this program are those of the speakers and do not necessarily reflect the views or positions of Plan First Wealth.
Information presented is for educational purposes only and does not intend to make an offer or solicitation for the sale or purchase of any specific securities, investments, or investment strategies. Investments involve risk and unless otherwise stated, are not guaranteed. Be sure to first consult with a qualified financial adviser and/or tax professional before implementing any strategy discussed herein. Plan First Wealth does not provide any tax and/or legal advice and strongly recommends that listeners seek their own advice in these areas.
ABOUT RICHARD:
Richard Taylor is a British expat, dual citizen (UK & US). Originally from Bolton, he now lives in Greenwich, CT, where Plan First Wealth has its head office.
As the firm’s leader, Richard launched Taylor & Taylor, now Plan First Wealth, and continues to fuel the firm’s growth. Richard is a Chartered Financial Planner (UK – CII) in addition to holding the IMC (CFA UK) and Series 65 (US – FINRA).
Connect with Richard on LinkedIn
TRANSCRIPT:
Richard Taylor:
[00:00:00 – 00:00:12]
You know, we had one client freaking out because they thought they were going to have to get a certificate for every single year. In my experience, that’s not the case. You get a certificate for this for the same year that you’re starting withdrawals or you need the withdrawals, and it stays in place as long as you’re taking withdrawals.
James Boyle:
[00:00:12 – 00:00:32]
You go to your 401k provider and say, or your IRA provider and say, I’m retired. I’d like to take some money. And they say, okay, great. You’ve got 800,000. A million in that 401k, 2 million. You have to distribute all that in full. You get taxed on it at your highest marginal rates in that tax year. I mean, you know, you’re talking about half the value gone.
Richard Taylor:
[00:00:32 – 00:02:13]
We’ve had clients doing these for 10 years, and suddenly in the last six months, it’s just all gone a bit wrong. You must start taking withdrawals for at least six weeks before applying for an NT tax code. Welcome to Expat Wealth, a Plan first wealth podcast dedicated to helping ambitious British expatriates living in America to thrive here. I’m your host, Richard Taylor, and Plan first wealth is the business I founded and run today alongside my business partner and co host, James Boyle. And we work with successful British expatriates living across America to make the most of their opportunity while avoiding the expat landmines. And boy, are there a lot of landmines in America. But first, a quick disclaimer. While Plan First Wealth, LLC is an SEC registered investment advisor, the views and opinions expressed in this program are those of the speakers and do not necessarily reflect the views and positions of Plan First Wealth. Information presented is for educational purposes only. Now, if you aren’t already receiving our emails, please go to our website, www.planfirstwealth.com and sign up there. It’s free and you’ll be notified every time we drop a new episode and so much more. Okay, on today’s from the Trenches, you, James and I bring you behind the scenes here at Plan first wealth as we build this business together and we work with our expatriate clients trying to make a difference for them and for their families. If you have questions for James and I, we will try and answer them on the show and if we can’t, we’ll find someone who can. Email us your questions at Expat Wealth. Plan First Wealth.com so without further ado, let’s get into it. Hey, James.
James Boyle:
[00:02:13 – 00:02:14]
How’s it going? Richard,.
Richard Taylor:
[00:02:15 – 00:02:16]
It’s going well. How about yourself?
James Boyle:
[00:02:17 – 00:02:22]
Good. Are you. Are you awash in Halloween costumes and decorations and things?
Richard Taylor:
[00:02:22 – 00:03:39]
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. The boys have got theirs ready. It’s on a Saturday, this, this weekend. So I’m all right. I’m a bit of, a. Bit of a grump when it comes to Halloween. Right. I’ve never really got it. I am a bit of a grump. My wife really rubs me ribs me for it. And I’ve kind of resisted it for 10 years because. Because America goes wild for it. Right. But there is a street adjacent to us, like just at the end of our road that’s like the neighborhood street, you know, it’s truly where the whole. The street goes completely bonkers for Halloween and people travel in for this street. Every neighborhood has one of these streets. And we’re lucky that ours is right at the end of our road. And I’ve gone from kind of being like non plus to kind of into it. And then this year it being Saturday, so I don’t have work the next day. And I was Friday last year, but Saturday this year, and I’ll go down with my neighbor. I get on great, my neighbor, and we’ll have like a few tinnies down. And I. I’m not dressing up. Although I was tempted to suggest him to go as a Gallagher brothers, but it wouldn’t, Wouldn’t really. It wouldn’t really land here in America in the same way. So I’m not dressing up. My kids are. And I’m. I gotta tell you, I’m kind of excited. I, I wouldn’t say I’ve completely embraced Halloween 11 years in, but I, I’m almost there.
James Boyle:
[00:03:40 – 00:03:45]
It’s an American holiday, really. Right. We kind of took it and ran with it with the costumes and everything.
Richard Taylor:
[00:03:45 – 00:03:48]
Yeah, you really, you guys. God, you love dressing up.
James Boyle:
[00:03:50 – 00:03:50]
That’s one.
Richard Taylor:
[00:03:50 – 00:04:01]
I can’t say fancy dress because when I first said fancy dress, which every Brit will know is dressing up for whatever you guys call it, Americans thought I meant like putting on like a black tie.
James Boyle:
[00:04:02 – 00:04:02]
Suit and tie.
Richard Taylor:
[00:04:03 – 00:04:58]
No, I told me. Yeah. Talking about wearing fancy dresses. Like, what, you going to a black tie event or something? I always found that very funny. Yeah. So listen, I’ve also, I’ve got the. I’ve got the TV on. I’ve always got Sky News on here and it’s the UK budget. And. Yeah, it’s just one of those things the UK does. The US doesn’t do that. Now I’m here, I’m kind of like, why. Why do we do this like that. The. I actually, I couldn’t even tell you what’s, what’s come out of it, so I’ve not been paying attention. I’ll digest it all later. But just every year, the kind of the, the UK loses its mind in the month running up to the budget. It’s just all this drama for nothing. And then, and then I’ve just. I’ve just seen that the, the Conservative leader, Kemi Badenok, she’s come on and started, you know, ripping into it. And I just realized, like, she has to. It’s like, it’s almost like, performative. You ever wonder, like, what would happen if, if an opposition leader got up and went, you know what? That’s all right,.
James Boyle:
[00:04:58 – 00:04:59]
Pretty good. There’s.
Richard Taylor:
[00:04:59 – 00:05:37]
Some things, there’s some things I do differently, but, you know, by and large, I’m okay with this. Counterintuitively, I actually wonder if that might go down better with some people once in a while. Because I just look at, at Kemi B. Not come up here and just like, lay into it. I’m like, yeah, of course you’re going to say that. You have to say that. Like, no matter what they’re doing, you’re going to, you’re going to, you’re going to rip it to shreds. And like, I just wondering. I think people are getting cynical with that, with all of our politicians, not just British politicians, all of politicians. And just I wonder if a different approach. Maybe I’m being hopelessly naive and idealistic here, but I do wonder if a different approach might yield better results.
James Boyle:
[00:05:37 – 00:05:38]
I would love to see that.
Richard Taylor:
[00:05:39 – 00:05:40]
It’s not gonna happen.
James Boyle:
[00:05:40 – 00:05:42]
It’s not gonna happen. No way.
Richard Taylor:
[00:05:42 – 00:06:16]
I mean, we can hope. We can hope there’s a better world out there for all of us. So, Right, let’s get stuck into this. We’re gonna talk about SIPs again and UK pensions, because that seems to be a hot topic for us right now. But before we do that, our last from the Trenches episode, we talked about the NT tax code, and we’ve never had a, a better response. I wouldn’t say a better response, but we’ve never had so many people reach out to us afterwards sharing their experiences, which are not good.
James Boyle:
[00:06:16 – 00:06:26]
The, the sheer volume of comments, questions, just sympathy we heard from the audience. Good to hear because obviously it’s a, it’s a topic that is on people’s minds.
Richard Taylor:
[00:06:27 – 00:07:19]
Well, I think let’s, let’s share a quick update. So, NT tax code. So James and I talked about it last episode, last from The Trenches episode. I actually don’t know what the number that is. Pro hundred or something like that. And we got in. We’ve had for the first time in 11 years of being here, we’ve started having anti tax codes rejected and we were kind of scratching our heads just saying we’re not sure what’s going on here guys and just be warned. And then since then a number of people have reached out to us saying yeah, I’ve had this experience and I found out more since then. So anyway, quick update number one. One of my stories was we had a client had his anti tax code rejected because HMRC said the SIP wasn’t a pension under the trees which just, I still can’t wrap my head around that. Anyway, we did a webinar and someone in the comments had the same issue. Not a client.
James Boyle:
[00:07:20 – 00:07:21]
Right. Different platform.
Richard Taylor:
[00:07:22 – 00:07:23]
Was it a different platform?
James Boyle:
[00:07:23 – 00:07:25]
I don’t. Maybe he didn’t mention what the platform.
Richard Taylor:
[00:07:25 – 00:08:02]
Didn’t mention that I would, I’d be surprised. I suspect it’s the same one. Just guessing, don’t know for sure but I bet you it’s the same trustee. So that’s two clients who had their NT tax code rejected by HMRC who are saying the sip, they’re in the UK regulated sip, self invested personal pension is not a pension under the treaty, which is just categorically wrong and insane. But there we are. Anyway, our client has written to HMRC with evidence. We’ll wait and see what happens. Hopefully they’ll go, yeah, sorry governor, we got that one wrong. Here’s your NT tax code. So.
James Boyle:
[00:08:03 – 00:08:09]
Did, did that client try to call? I know it’s a pain to try to call. Curiosity. Okay. Because that’s.
Richard Taylor:
[00:08:09 – 00:08:10]
Not as far as I’m aware.
James Boyle:
[00:08:10 – 00:08:45]
Yeah, a lot of these times it’s hard to get a direct answer from HMRC without actually speaking to someone and then hoping you you speak with someone who’s sensible and knowledgeable and knows what’s going on. I have a quick update on that too. Just to tag onto it, I had a actually client meeting this week as record yesterday who had submitted all the forms. IRS stamped the residency certificate like all looked good. Got to hmrc, they rejected it for no date on the form on page. I think it’s page three or something like that where they asked about income. Well.
Richard Taylor:
[00:08:45 – 00:08:46]
The client hadn’t dated it.
James Boyle:
[00:08:47 – 00:09:02]
The client hadn’t dated it. Yeah. Yeah. And that would lend more credence to the process being you already have to have started income from the sip, from the pension to apply for The NT tax code.
Richard Taylor:
[00:09:03 – 00:11:06]
Well, I. Let me add to that because one of the emails I received two points. One was from someone who had the code rejected because. So just to remind everyone, there’s two parts of the process. You, you have to send something off to the irs and the IRS issue a certificate that says you’re a taxpayer, a U.S. taxpayer for that particular year. This is an important part for that particular year. They’re then meant to send that to HMRC who will then update or hopefully give you an anti tax code for that year and that should stay in place. We had one client freaking out because they thought they were going to have to get a certificate for every single year. In my experience, that’s not the case. You get a certificate for the same year that you’re starting withdrawals or you need the withdrawals and it stays in place as long as you’re taking withdrawals. Anyway. We had a client and the IRS are meant to send that form to hmrc, right? But, but I have heard instances of them sending it back, back to the, back to you and then you send it to hmrc. So God, you know, what a mess. Anyway, this client got a certificate. It was sent to hmrc, but it was the next year. So let’s just say they got a certificate for 2025, but by the time it reached HMRC, we’re in 2026. Marc rejected it because it was for a different, it was for a different tax year to the year they’re now in. Which is insanely frustrating because this client’s then said that’s great, but now I’ve applied again and now we’re nearing the end of the tax year and it’s gone into this black hole of the irs. So we have one, we have one for a client who’s starting for the first time and we are starting the process in January. So in January we are going to start a withdrawal from their SIP to trigger a tax code which is going to link into a point I’m about to make in a second. And we are then going to apply to IRS for a certificate so they have a full 12 months to create the certificate, send it to HMRC and hopefully, I don’t know what else we can do. Hopefully that will work.
James Boyle:
[00:11:07 – 00:11:36]
That is exactly the idea I discussed with this client is it seems like he’s going to try to call, I believe, but it seems like we’re going to have to take a taxable withdrawal in January that’s going to give him a date of when taxable income started. And then resubmit and hope that the turnaround time is quick enough. This does seem like a concerted effort on hmrc. This is pure speculation, but it seems like HMRC has really cracked down on these. Right. That’s what all the evidence seems to be pointing to.
Richard Taylor:
[00:11:36 – 00:12:09]
We’ve had clients doing these for 10 years and suddenly in the last six months it’s just all gone a bit wrong. So I don’t know what to make from that, but that’s where we are. So I had another email from someone called Monty. Monty, I’m sorry, I owe you a response. This got buried in my emails but I’m. I will respond. He spoke to HMRC and well, one somewhere his, his wife’s application got lost. She has to start that one again. But they did confirm to him he must start taking withdrawals for at least six weeks before applying for an NT tax code.
James Boyle:
[00:12:10 – 00:12:11]
Six weeks. So.
Richard Taylor:
[00:12:11 – 00:12:11]
There’s an.
James Boyle:
[00:12:11 – 00:12:13]
Actual time frame? Apparently.
Richard Taylor:
[00:12:13 – 00:12:18]
So yeah. I didn’t. New to me. I don’t want to say for that. That’s where you are.
James Boyle:
[00:12:18 – 00:12:31]
Watch this space. It feels like every time we ask for or hear from HMRC or communication from hmrc, it’s different or there’s some new wrinkle or layer of consideration that hadn’t been the case before.
Richard Taylor:
[00:12:33 – 00:14:39]
Right. And we want to drill down into UK pensions today because this is a big part of what we do. We are a cross border uk, UK US wealth manager, financial planner. We support British expats, living, coming to, living in, retiring in, in America and also returning back to the UK or elsewhere, but primarily living in, working in, retiring in America. And as a result of that we do a lot of UK pension business. We do more US business, we manage more US assets, we manage more IRAs, US brokerage accounts for our British expat clients than we do, than we do pensions. But pensions are UK pension. SIPs are a significant part of our business because of who our clients are. As you’ve heard me say a million times, these are people who came over mid career and they had assets in the UK and we help. We’re one of the very few firms who can help manage assets the UK US in a conjoined plan and understand all the complexities and help people avoid the landmines, yada yada yada. Also if you’ve heard me say a million times. But is it incredibly frustrating because the US stuff is just so much better and easier to deal with and clients get used to that and they think this is the standard and then these UK pensions are a pain in the backside. Even the best solutions are 10 times more painful than dealing with us stuff which isn’t painful at all. And we find that it create, we almost take that, we almost get, get, get punched on the nose for, for this stuff because like we can deal with it and someone’s got to deal with it. But then people get very, very frustrated sometimes with us with these difficulties. So we want to just spend some time talking about UK pensions and SIPs and some of the challenges and hopefully whether people are clients of ours or not, we can manage some expectations.
James Boyle:
[00:14:39 – 00:15:30]
It is, if I can just say from kind of a starting point coming from the American bias. Obviously everyone, if you’re listening to this for the first time, you hear my accent. But it is shocking to me what UK pension companies can get away with in the name of sort of call it regulation or compliance or consumer protection and essentially block the end user, the pension holder from accessing their own funds. Whether that’s drawdown, whether that’s taking money out, whether it’s moving money around. In the us Again from an American bias perspective, you sort of have free rein to do that, right? Depending on, or your advisor in the us you can, you can discuss, implement a plan to move money around, shift money, access it whenever you need it. That is not at all the case with,.
Richard Taylor:
[00:15:31 – 00:15:54]
You know what it’s like. These trustees and these administrators put up every single barrier they can and cynically I believe that some of them are doing it on purpose because they are what we’ll talk about in a second. They’re zombie insurance companies. They don’t take on new business and they don’t want to lose, they just want to retain these assets as long as they can. That’s my conspiracy theory. But what they would say,.
James Boyle:
[00:15:54 – 00:15:59]
I mean there’s certainly an incentive, right? They’re collecting fees on, on these pensions and yeah.
Richard Taylor:
[00:16:00 – 00:17:09]
Is, yeah, yeah but there’s, there’s, there’s been numerous scams and miss selling scandals. And you know what? They’re right, there have been, they’ve been from, from people moving out of pensions that they shouldn’t have done. People moving from into more expensive arrangements which is not like, you know, it’s not good, but it’s not the worst thing in the world to outright scams, you know, true scams, pensions disappearing. Yes, that absolutely happened. But what I’ve learned from being in the US is it doesn’t have to be that way. You have here complete freedom. Almost like you, you could, you, it’s your money you move around with it, you’ve got to be careful. But. But you don’t have all these guardians stopping you access your money. And there also aren’t a plethora of sc. I know everyone’s not being scammed out. No, it is happening more and more. This pig butchering stuff that’s going on and AI, you know, there is stuff going on, but in the UK it was, it was endemic. It’s not here. So it doesn’t. It. I, I used to kind of buy. Oh, you know, it’s a necessary evil. It’s not.
James Boyle:
[00:17:11 – 00:17:20]
Fascinating. Yeah, yeah. Because it’s almost. It’s, you know, it’s putting up obstacles where maybe there didn’t need to be as many or.
Richard Taylor:
[00:17:20 – 00:17:32]
But why. Why in the uk, in the US do you not have these obstacles and everyone isn’t being scammed on the pension, whereas in the UK they have all these obstacles and still people are being scammed out of their pensions. Like what. What are we getting so badly wrong in the UK.
James Boyle:
[00:17:33 – 00:17:33]
Anyway?
Richard Taylor:
[00:17:33 – 00:18:46]
Listen, let’s get. I’m ranting now. So let’s. What we’re going to do into two parts. We’re going to talk about. We help people get into international SIPs. There’s no such thing as an international SIP. Before everyone gets angry with me, there’s only things, such things as SIPs we call international SIPs because these are SIPs set up for people living outside the UK. So they just have more options, more flexibility, more awareness about dealing with non UK people. So they’re just better for people like our clients. And then we’re also going to talk on some of the negatives of UK pensions. So I’ll tell you what, should we start with the bad news? Always start with bad news. I say. So let’s talk about the negatives of UK pensions. You’re not going to talk about defined benefit pensions, not final, sorry, pensions. They’re an entirely different thing all on their own. So nothing good or bad to say about those. We’re talking about defined contribution money purchase schemes, like pots of money, be it a. A company pension scheme that you were, that you contributed to when you were working in the uk, or a personal pension or a stakeholder pension. You know, you’ve moved to America, you’ve got two or three of these old pensions languishing around. What’s the problem? Passing the book to you.
James Boyle:
[00:18:46 – 00:20:24]
Okay. They say with it. I mean, you touched on this. Right? Is the thing that comes up time and time again, often is access. Right. Just being able to access Your funds, your pension funds, your retirement funds, we should say here, too. I don’t think this will come as a surprise to anyone listening. Some of these obstacles, some of these headaches are endemic to the UK pension system itself. Virtually all of them are going to be made more difficult, more of a headache, harder to navigate as a U.S. resident. Right. So you’ve got two layers of problematic access here. Not only do pension providers put up every obstacle in your way to access these funds or transfer them, they’ll also see that you’re a US person and frankly, don’t want to deal with you. I think that’s probably a fair characterization. We have clients or people we work with who have pensions from 10, 20, 25 years ago. In fact, the case we’re working on right now, where this pension provider will only work on paper mail, right. When everything wet, signed by post, certified documents by post, and ultimately, when we finally do get answers, they’ve told them, oh, your only option to access this money is to distribute. Now, this is a couple that has multiple pensions among them, all with the same provider. Distribute all of them in full. So.
Richard Taylor:
[00:20:24 – 00:20:45]
It’s either leave it as it is, buy an annuity, which you can’t do in America, you can’t buy annuities, you can’t take your UK pension and buy a UK annuity. So that’s not an option. They don’t have a drawdown option is what you’re saying. Right, right. Some, A lot of pensions, UK pensions now do, but not all. They don’t have a drawdown option. So they’re saying you’re going to dispute it all in full.
James Boyle:
[00:20:46 – 00:20:52]
Yep. Or transfer it. And, and we’re going to make the transfer very difficult. Right.
Richard Taylor:
[00:20:52 – 00:20:53]
That’s,.
James Boyle:
[00:20:53 – 00:21:32]
You know, that’s the underlying implication and, you know, just to spel for listeners. And again, all of this shocks me from an American perspective, but that would be like, you go into your 401k provider, you’ve retired, you go to your 401 provider and say, or your IRA provider and say, hey, I’m retired, I’d like to take some money. And they say, okay, great, you’ve got 800,000, a million in that 401, 2 million. You have to distribute all that in full. You get taxed on it at your highest marginal rates in that tax year. I mean, you know, you’re talking about half the value gone just because there wasn’t any flexibility at all that they’ve provided you for accessing the money in a sensible way.
Richard Taylor:
[00:21:32 – 00:23:02]
I’m excited to Announce that Expat wealth has its first sponsor, the Global Financial Planning Institute. The GFPI exists to provide education, community tools, resources and ongoing research for financial planners and other advanced financial professionals working with international and cross border clients in the US And Americans abroad. I’m a GFP Institute fellow and I’ve put all our employees through their GFPI programs when they join us. I’ve met some great people, I’ve learned a ton. It’s a genuine community of internationally minded folk doing their best to serve their clients properly and critically sharing what they know in the oftentimes challenging and ambiguous US cross border environment. And as anyone in this sector will tell you, you’re always learning. So if you work with international clients and or Americans abroad, or if this is an area you’re looking to get into, check out the gfpi@www.gfp.in stute you will be glad you did and I hope to see you there soon. So we’ve got these, we’ve got these all star pensions. Depending on how old they are, they might be really expensive, they might not be. You know, we’re asking more and more now which have ritual from within the last 10 years and they’re definitely not expensive but what they are is they have really rubbish investment options and often, oftentimes to get the best price you’re limited in the, the insured fund range. And they’re like, you get, you know that whole thing values. What Price is what you pay. Value is what you get. Okay, you’re not paying very much for it but like there’s a reason.
James Boyle:
[00:23:02 – 00:23:02]
For it.
Richard Taylor:
[00:23:02 – 00:23:47]
You’re in there like really crap managed fund. Like so believe for you you’re saving half a percent a year but, but over 30 years or 20 years or however long you leave it languishing there. What’s that going to cost you in, in missed, in opportunity costs in missed returns. Not that anyone can promise returns, but I can, you know, I can promise you a crap fund is going to be a crap fund. So you got, you got, you got possibly expensive, maybe not, but even when it’s maybe not like you haven’t got great options. And on the investment side probably JB who recently joined us. So JB turns out JB told his he got a pension with Aegon. I told him he’s in the US and they’ve said you need to go to cash right now and you can only invest in our insured range of fund, which will probably be crap.
James Boyle:
[00:23:48 – 00:24:13]
You’re a captive audience, right? And you kind of don’t have an option other than the transfers, which we’re going to talk about. But we had another case earlier in the year where same thing the provider told them, we’re going to sell out of your investments on a sizable chunk of this person’s assets, go to cash and we don’t work with US persons. Good luck to you. It was basically what was told to them. It’s shocking again that that’s a lot. They can do that.
Richard Taylor:
[00:24:14 – 00:26:35]
And I’m going to name and shame here. So we have, we have something going through right now for a client, the Standard Life. And it turns out so Standard Life just. This is not a particularly big pension, right? But it’s also, I mean, no one wants to leave any money. You’ve got money in a pension, it’s your money, right? So even if it’s like 10 grand, that’s your money. This is a lot more than 10 grand. But it’s not like big in the grand scheme of things. But it’s enough that this kind one, you know, it’s, it’s a, it’s a serious number in isolation and it’s just been languishing in this pension for, for good knows how long we’ve come along and said, right, we can help you get hold of this, manage it better and get access to it when you need it, right? And holy hell, it’s looking like it might not even happen. They’ve. It’s Standard Life. They’ve put up every single roadblock possible and to the point where this client’s like, yeah, should we just, should we just leave this? What’s the point? And like, I get it, like, we’re also completely fed up of this whole process, but ultimately, like you. So at some point you, that you have to power through this, otherwise you’re never going to get this money. It’s wild that we’re saying this. And I should say we also, we met with a trustee of another pension company recently and expressed some of these frustrations and they told us that this is a big deal in the UK right now. There’s like a thematic review or something looking into these practices and I’m not surprised. So it turns out I’ve been railing against this for years. One of the, one of the, one of our old favorites used to be Phoenix Life. Turns out, so in the UK, 30, 40 years ago, there were tens, maybe even hundreds of insurance companies, right, and they were all flogging pensions and whatnot. And then in the past 20 years, they’ve just consolidated from from tens or hundreds to like maybe 10 big insurance companies. They’ve just got small and small. But a lot of them are what I call zombie insurance companies where they, they don’t do any new business, they just service existing policies. And as I, we talked about before, my conspiracy theory is they make it impossible to get out. So listen to this. This is on the Standard Life website, Phoenix Life, because now apparently they’re all part of the same group. And my, my suspicions just get worse because they are close to new customers, they are able to focus their energy and expertise on delivering excellent outcomes for existing customers. Lies.
James Boyle:
[00:26:36 – 00:26:37]
It hasn’t been my experience how.
Richard Taylor:
[00:26:37 – 00:26:38]
Long you get sued here.
James Boyle:
[00:26:39 – 00:27:54]
Yeah, we’ll have to bleep these names maybe. But it goes to the theory, right, that there is a perverse incentive scheme from my American perspective that allows these companies to operate with impunity. Basically when it comes to these investors, these workers, hard earned pension funds, dollars, pounds that they’ve worked for, which is shocking and touched on something really important there. We share the frustration, we wish it was easier and we do everything we can and we partner with firms who make things better or improve things where they can within this framework. But it is not easy dealing with these companies. It really isn’t. And when you’ve had all of your experience, this is what we opened with and we’re going to talk about SIPs here, but when all of your experience has been in the US world or most of it, when you’ve come here mid career, you’re investing in a 401 IRA, maybe you’ve moved things around once or twice, that becomes the assumption, right? That’s how we move assets around, that’s how easy it is. Then they have an experience with a UK pension company and it is the opposite. And that is frustrating. And we hear that it’s not easy to navigate, but you have to eventually. It’s a small.
Richard Taylor:
[00:27:54 – 00:29:28]
Preview you’ve got to deal with and we’ll do everything we can. And sometimes depending on the provider, it’s easier, sometimes it’s almost impossible, but kind of just got to persevere. Otherwise what you do, just, just accept that no one’s getting this money until you die. Like no, Come on. So let’s talk about international SIPs or SIPs, right? Why, why do we think most people, not everyone, I, I actually just spoke to a couple in the UK yesterday, a younger couple with small UK pensions and I said like, think about where they are, but, but leave them in a personal pension for now. There’s a Variety of reasons why that. But, but nine will recommend someone moves into an international sip. Why? Really, three reasons that immediately spring to mind. FX being able to control the currency. Massive. For someone retiring in America, massive investment options. You got an almost unlimited universe of investment options. Not completely unlimited. Right. We’re not putting private stuff or anything in there. But like in the listed universe you can, you could, we’ve got, we can do pretty much anything, which is great. So investment options and access when you need it, we can get this money out. Sometimes it takes longer than we like depending on who the trustee and administrator are, but we can ultimately get it for you. I should say you can get it. And they’re the three main reasons.
James Boyle:
[00:29:28 – 00:30:22]
Yep. And there’s a lot we could talk about in, in each of those three. But the fact that we have to talk about access to your money again, I know we’re beating this drum, but that is a very real benefit to looking at these account types because frankly that might not exist in the current structure. FX very, very easy to overlook. The risk that exchange rate, that currency swings, currency volatility introduces into someone’s plan. It’s something that’s easy to overlook, but in bad time periods, talk about stock market swings, stock market volatility, currencies can fluctuate 20%, 30%, 40% in a very quick period. If you have a good chunk of your retirement savings of your pension assets in GBP and you’re buying bread and milk and paying a mortgage and property tax in USD, that is an enormous risk that needs to be mitigated within the plan.
Richard Taylor:
[00:30:22 – 00:30:23]
Enormous risk.
James Boyle:
[00:30:25 – 00:30:44]
The fact that these international SIPs, what we refer to them as, that they exist, is a gift to people who are in the cross border space because it really is the best vehicle to start to wrangle these UK pensions, as difficult as it might be upfront and get them folded into the plan, get them working for you instead of against you.
Richard Taylor:
[00:30:45 – 00:32:15]
And investment wise, no one can guarantee investment. What I’m going to say, take it all with a pinch of salt. But as I said before, if you’re in these, these company pension schemes, these old personal pensions, stakeholder pensions, which would, which was super cheap, you’ve not got a wide universe of investment choices. And what you have got, especially if you’ve been limited, because in America probably isn’t great, you’re probably in the insurance company’s own funds. These are not the best funds. Maybe you’re getting them for cheap, maybe not, but maybe you are. But if you’re getting, if you’re in an insurance company’s managed fund and let’s say it’s averaging 5% a year, and you could be. But you’re only paying half a percent. Right. And you, you could be in a. In a, In a, In a, In a. In a proper port, what I’m going to call a proper portfolio of investments. And let’s say that’s. That averages 6, 7, 8% a year, but you’re paying 1% or one and a half total in fees to all parties, which would be a lot. But let’s just. Just say that’s what you’re paying. Like you’re better off. Like you. Over time, that will make a significant difference and that is a difference between some being stuck in a rubbish or, as I said before, crap fund versus a modern, you know, ETF or ETFs. Should I say a proper, modern portfolio. So, yeah, it really is night and day.
James Boyle:
[00:32:16 – 00:32:33]
Yes. So if we can wrap up. It is frustrating. We share your frustrations. We do everything we can to make it easier. Know that there are options right there, There are, there is a pathway to, like I said, wrangle these things and get them into your control and let you access your own money. Is that so much to ask?
Richard Taylor:
[00:32:34 – 00:32:44]
And don’t just wait till you’re 55, 60 inside to think about retirement, because that is 20 years, 15 years, 10 years of opportunity cost down the drain.
James Boyle:
[00:32:44 – 00:32:51]
Yep. We talk about opportunity cost a lot. It’s a very real cost. Something, again, easy to overlook, too.
Richard Taylor:
[00:32:51 – 00:33:01]
Yeah. All right. Moving on to happier things. Pick a mix. Right, what have you got for me? I know you’re. I know you’re chomping at the bit on this one.
James Boyle:
[00:33:01 – 00:33:09]
I had this one locked and loaded, so you have to see this documentary called Elizabeth.
Richard Taylor:
[00:33:09 – 00:33:09]
Holmes.
James Boyle:
[00:33:09 – 00:33:12]
See everything. Yes. You haven’t seen it, have you?
Richard Taylor:
[00:33:12 – 00:33:13]
I haven’t seen it yet, but I’m going to.
James Boyle:
[00:33:13 – 00:33:37]
You have to see it. I’m not going to spoil anything. Yeah, well, it’s like I was laughing with a friend we were talking about after I said you could create a movie, a documentary in a lab and you’d be hard pressed to find something more fitted for my creepy brain. It’s just perfectly set up. Nathan Fielder. Fantastic work.
Richard Taylor:
[00:33:38 – 00:33:46]
I don’t know this guy, but I’ve read about him and heard about him through this documentary, and I’ve always thought, I bet James loved this guy. Loves this guy. Is that.
James Boyle:
[00:33:46 – 00:33:48]
Right? You know me too well. Do.
Richard Taylor:
[00:33:48 – 00:33:49]
You like Bo Burnham?
James Boyle:
[00:33:49 – 00:34:25]
Yeah. Yeah. He came a little bit after me. I Think so. I wasn’t quite on the. He’s a bit younger. I think his audience. Fielder’s right in my, in my, in my wheelhouse. And even the director of this guy, Lance Oppenheim, who’s done a number of other projects that I really like. He’s only 30, by the way. He’s like wunderkind. Just everyone go watch it. It’s fascinating. I think it’s a bit of a microcosm look at the American sort of economy. If I could be so bold and who populates it and these larger than life figures and how they operate, how they navigate the world.
Richard Taylor:
[00:34:26 – 00:35:01]
She’s such a villain, isn’t she? She’s such a villain. And I know you could say that all these tech giants, tech titans are villains and she’s the one in prison. And you know this. I definitely think there’s something to that argument. But she in isolation, she is such a villain. And I hear she’s not contrite at all and nothing’s her fault. And I hear the. The boyfriend is pretty sinister in this arm. Looking forward to. I’m looking forward to that Was always a weird one. He’s like a rich scion of a hotel family. Much younger. It’s just the whole thing is weird. Yeah. I can see it being an indictment on America. And.
James Boyle:
[00:35:01 – 00:35:10]
I know we like to talk about books, so I’ll just shout out and I might have actually read this within the lifetime of the podcast, but there’s a book called Bad Blood by a writer called John. Carrie.
Richard Taylor:
[00:35:10 – 00:35:42]
John carry you. Yeah. Yeah. I moved to America in 2015 and she was still a fetid billionaire. And I remember thinking, wow, she’s like my age. And then I remember reading that first Wall Street Journal, kind of. I’d only been here about six months. That first Wall Street Journal. No, it wasn’t a takedown. It was like a. Something’s not right here. And then. And then followed the story from there. What a story. I watched something your recommendation this weekend. Obsession.
James Boyle:
[00:35:42 – 00:35:43]
Ah. What do you think?
Richard Taylor:
[00:35:45 – 00:36:03]
Fantastic. I. I would. Yeah. To be that grit by a movie. We’re all too addicted to our phones and I, I for one spend far too much time on my phone in front of the tv. And this really drew us in. And then when you. When you hear that it’s done by a kid, basically, or no budget. We’re moving into a different time here. And fair play.
James Boyle:
[00:36:03 – 00:36:10]
It’s really exciting. Yeah. When you hear these like 24 year olds who, who something that arrives like that, that’s so fully formed.
Richard Taylor:
[00:36:10 – 00:36:10]
James Boyle:
[00:36:11 – 00:36:14]
Yeah. I don’t. He might have been 26. He’s young. I know he’s. Yeah.
Richard Taylor:
[00:36:15 – 00:36:15]
No budget.
James Boyle:
[00:36:16 – 00:36:18]
Yeah. 500, 000. Did.
Richard Taylor:
[00:36:18 – 00:36:19]
This himself. Not through a studio. Right.
James Boyle:
[00:36:20 – 00:36:29]
I think they may have had some financing somewhere. But like I said, you know, that’s peanuts to these production companies and yeah, it’s exciting those things.
Richard Taylor:
[00:36:29 – 00:37:08]
Yeah, Yeah, I enjoyed that. Yeah. No, I’m going to watch that. I’m going to watch the Elizabeth Holmes documentary. I’m. I’m reading two books at the moment. I’m reading a book called Gotham which is on the. It’s this book on New York City from. From the, from the time basically the Dutch came over to I think 1900 or 1898. And it’s. It’s fascinating. But there’s this great podcast called the Only Way is History which I absolutely love. And they constant mock American authors for just writing excessively long biographies and books. And they. And I take some umbrella shacks. I do enjoy some like David McCulloch. I love it.
James Boyle:
[00:37:08 – 00:37:09]
Yeah.
Richard Taylor:
[00:37:09 – 00:37:40]
Right. So. But this is a book where I’m both enjoying it and thinking holy crap, this is a. This is, this is. This is kind of a lot here. You could cut some of this out. And so I’m enjoying it. And I also learned an interesting fact. I shared this with you yesterday. There’s an area of New York right down at the bottom, you know, near the Williamsburg Bridge, where it kind of pokes out a little bit that’s called Corlea’s Hook. Corlea’s Hook. And it used to be an area rife with prostitution. And that’s where we get the word hookers from to this day.
James Boyle:
[00:37:40 – 00:37:43]
Wow. See Americans, we’re still given.
Richard Taylor:
[00:37:43 – 00:37:57]
Exporting so much culture to the world. Anyway, so I’m reading this book and I kind of had to. I just had to take a break from it for a minute just. So I’ve downloaded a book called the Curious Case of Mike Lynch. Do you know who Lynch’s.
James Boyle:
[00:37:57 – 00:37:57]
No.
Richard Taylor:
[00:37:58 – 00:39:43]
Mike lynch was the British answer to Bill Gates. Very, very long story short here built a company called Autonomy, sold it to HP for. Made him a billionaire. HP sued him for accounting frauds practices. He was found guilty civilly in the uk. He ended up getting extradited to America, went to a high profile trial in America into 2024. Improbably with a 0.4% chance was found not guilty which is an indictment the American system. Because he probably was guilty but he had all this money. Whereas if you have. If you have no money, you’re basically getting crushed by the system. Anyway, that’s a whole different podcast and talk for discussion. So he’d been on under house arrest in New in San Francisco for a year. Was improbably found not guilty in June 2024. In August 2024, his 60 meter or no, no, it’s much bigger than that. It’s an enormous boat. The Bainesian was caught in a tornado. Tornado off Sicily went down. He died with his 18 year old daughter. The lawyer in that case who was a. It was a high profile lawyer and a couple of others. And it’s a. It’s just the whole thing is a fascinating, fascinating, sad bit tawdry tale. And I’m reading a book about his life and about what went on Autonomy, which I again I have to say I think probably was fraud vigilant. His CFO went to prison five years earlier in America. Crazy story. You should look it up. I actually think you’ll now mention it. You’ll probably remember because it was a big story at the time when this boat went down. It was struck by a random basic tornado just off the coast of Sicily and sunk like a stone. It’s very sad. His 18 year old daughter was on there.
James Boyle:
[00:39:43 – 00:39:48]
That the boat sounds familiar. I. I have to read this. That sounds right up my ass.
Richard Taylor:
[00:39:48 – 00:40:17]
Well, look, right. So. So yeah, I’ll tell you what. It. I mean I’m thoroughly enjoying the book because I’m so invested in the story. I followed it for years. I’m so invested in the story. It’s not a piece of literature that’s going to change the world. You know, like the smartest guys in the room or the. Whatever the book was that was on end. Run the book on. The book on. What was the one in 1998? Barbarians at the Gate. Phenomenal. The one on Long Term Asset Management. The one from Greenwich that went down in like 98, 99.
James Boyle:
[00:40:17 – 00:40:18]
Yeah,.
Richard Taylor:
[00:40:18 – 00:40:43]
That one. They’re kind of works of art. Too Big to Fail. This is not that. And I’m gonna. I’m gonna finish it in about three days, but for that maybe a bit longer. Maybe four or five days. But. But it, but I’m enjoying it. So I’m not. I’m not recommending it as like a. Like you’ve. You’ve got to read Too Big to Fail. Like I would say that. But if you’ve got interest in that story and I have and you might have. It’s a book you should read.
James Boyle:
[00:40:43 – 00:40:45]
Yeah, I’m gonna check that out. That sounds good.
Richard Taylor:
[00:40:46 – 00:40:50]
Okay, super. All right, James. Well, we’ve bashed UK pensions again.
James Boyle:
[00:40:51 – 00:40:51]
Yeah.
Richard Taylor:
[00:40:52 – 00:41:15]
Tell you what, if anyone’s got any feedback on anti tax codes, UK pension disasters, if you just want to slag off any UK pension providers, you know, we’re up. We will welcome that feedback and we’ll slag them off. Back to you as well. Expat wealth@planfirstwealth.com we’d love to hear from you. As always. Other than that, we’ll see you next time.
James Boyle:
[00:41:15 – 00:41:16]
Cheers. Thanks for listening.
Richard Taylor:
[00:41:17 – 00:42:26]
Bye bye. All right folks, that’s another episode of Expat wealth under our belts. Thank you for listening. I appreciate it and I appreciate you. If you’re enjoying the show and would like to support the mission, which is to help ambitious expats thrive in America, I’d ask you to subscribe to the podcast wherever you listen and also consider leaving a rating and review. This stuff really does matter. Please help us get this information to the people who need it, that is your fellow expats. Also, if you have any questions you would like answered on the show, you can get in touch with us at expat wealth plan first wealth.com just a quick reminder that this show is brought to you by Plant First Wealth. We are a US based financial planner and wealth manager and we help ambitious, successful international families living across the US to make the most of their opportunity and ultimately to retire happier. If you’d like to know more about how we might be able to help you retire, you can find us at our website, www.planfirstwealth.com or you can look me up on LinkedIn. Do get in touch. We’d love to hear from you. As always, thank you to the podcast guys for their help producing this episode and the entire show. See you next week.

